In its first two seasons, Schitt’s Creek showcased its comedic charm as a fish-out-of-water story. However, the series truly elevated from good to great in the season 2 finale, “Happy Anniversary,” largely due to Johnny Rose. In season 1, the Roses viewed themselves as superior to the town’s residents and were determined to escape their situation. By season 2, they began to face the reality that Schitt’s Creek might become their permanent home.
During their anniversary dinner in the season 2 finale, Johnny and Moira run into their old friends, the Taylors. The reunion starts off pleasantly but turns uncomfortable when the Schitts arrive. As Bev and Don Taylor begin to mock Schitt’s Creek, Johnny confronts them, addressing the situation head-on and making a significant impact on fans. He criticizes the Taylors for abandoning the Roses and acknowledges that, despite their imperfections, the Schitts have been true friends. This scene is pivotal for the series for a key reason.
Johnny Rose’s initial objective was to escape Schitt’s Creek and return to his prosperous, opulent life. Though he and his family tried to remain courteous to the townspeople, they often looked down on them. When faced with the Taylors’ snobbery and disloyalty, Johnny has a critical realization: the Roses had been just as contemptuous as the Taylors in their former lives. This moment marks Johnny’s genuine appreciation for what Schitt’s Creek has offered him.
Despite the town not matching the luxury the Roses once enjoyed, Johnny recognizes that it is filled with kind-hearted people who are eager to help. By standing up for Schitt’s Creek, Johnny acknowledges the positive impact it and the Schitts have had on his life. Although less materialistic than his family, Johnny is the first to demonstrate real growth.
Prior to Johnny’s speech, the Roses hadn’t been terrible people but were marked by arrogance and needed a lesson in humility. Johnny’s speech was the first sign of true growth, as he embraced Schitt’s Creek and defended it against the Taylors. This moment foreshadowed the personal development that would follow, with other Roses, like Alexis and David, also making significant strides. While “Happy Anniversary” may not be among Schitt’s Creek‘s finest episodes, it stands out as a crucial turning point in the Roses’ journey.
