A compelling theory about Schitt’s Creek suggests that Moira Rose (Catherine O’Hara) would never grow to love the town as her family did, and for a good reason. During their time in Schitt’s Creek, Johnny (Eugene Levy), David (Dan Levy), and Alexis (Annie Murphy) each found connections that made the town more bearable, whether through relationships, friendships, or business ventures. However, Moira appeared to be the least invested in the town.
Despite her flamboyance, Moira reveals her humble beginnings, which might explain her relationship with Schitt’s Creek. In season 1, episode 10, “Honeymoon,” Moira tells Jocelyn that she came from a small town like Schitt’s Creek and was desperate to leave, saying, “I couldn’t wait to get out, I was dying there.” Additionally, in season 2, episode 2, “Family Dinner,” her failed cooking skills make her nostalgic for her self-sufficiency before fame. For Moira, moving to Schitt’s Creek wasn’t a new experience like it was for Johnny, David, and Alexis, which is evident in her lack of connection to the town.
A theory (via Reddit) suggests that Moira had good reason not to love Schitt’s Creek because she had spent her life trying to escape a similar small town. Although she formed some attachments, like with the Jazzagals, she was not as deeply connected as Johnny, David, and Alexis were to their friends. Alexis, in particular, experienced significant personal growth due to her connections. Moira, driven by ambition, likely saw her return to a small town as a regression from her successful life, making it feel like her worst nightmare.
From the beginning of the show, Moira’s relationship with Alexis was strained, to the point where they struggled to have lunch together without planning topics in advance. Alexis’ constant traveling and Moira’s disconnection from her children’s lives contributed to their lack of bonding. However, living in Schitt’s Creek forced Moira and Alexis to confront their distance. Over time, Moira grew closer to Alexis, supporting her by hiring her as a PR manager and adjusting her Jazzagals performance to attend Alexis’ graduation. Their time in Schitt’s Creek helped Moira become more supportive and strengthen her relationship with Alexis.
Although Moira didn’t connect with Schitt’s Creek, her relationship with Alexis shows that she did change and grow as a person. Moira’s past in a small town meant she wasn’t as disconnected from Schitt’s Creek as it seemed. Her disconnection wasn’t due to a lack of personal growth but rather because living in a small town wasn’t a new experience for her. Moira had already escaped a small-town life she didn’t enjoy and was determined not to revert to it. This determination is reflected in her unwavering fashion choices and efforts to maintain her pre-Schitt’s Creek lifestyle.
In conclusion, Moira’s lack of connection to Schitt’s Creek doesn’t reflect negatively on her character. It highlights her unique journey and personal growth that differed from her family’s, rooted in her past experiences and ambitions.
4o
